11 N 3rd St Lafayette, IN 47901

About Farmers® Insurance – Jenna Isch

In August 2009, Jenna Isch opened the doors of her Lafayette, Indiana, Farmers® agency.

Jenna has earned the Farmers® New Business Award, as well as many other production awards during her time with Farmers®. She has qualified for the Toppers and Championship Achievement Clubs, which is awarded to the top agents nationwide. She has also been recognized locally. In 2010, Jenna was named on the “Top 10 Under 40” list by Tippy Connect Young Professionals. This award is granted to the leading young professionals in the Greater Lafayette community.

Since opening her Farmers® agency, Jenna has taken the initiative to become an active member of the Greater Lafayette, Indiana community, beginning with becoming a founding member of the Flashpoint Chapter of Business Networking International. She also serves on the Community Involvement Committee with Tippy Connect Young Professionals, as well as the Small Business of the Month Committee with the Greater Lafayette Commerce. Jenna is also a member of the Association of Women Business Owners.

Contact Us

Why Farmers® Insurance?

Insurance in Lafayette, Indiana House Insurance Car Insurance

Our insurance team is passionate about providing you with all of the options you need to create a personalized insurance plan that meets all of your insurance needs.

· Personalized Insurance Plans

· Proactive Customer Service

· One Stop Shopping

Farmers® Insurance - Jenna Isch’s Mission Statement

As your Lafayette, Indiana, Farmers® agency, we believe in helping you stay informed about the variety of ways to protect what is most important to you. Whether you are in need of auto insurance, life insurance, home insurance, specialized coverage, or all of these things, we can help. We are dedicated to providing you with the best options for your unique needs and circumstances so that together we can select the best plan for you.

Jenna Isch - Lafayette Insurance Agent 

Jenna Isch has called Greater Lafayette home since 2008 but is a lifelong Indiana native. She was born and raised in the small northeast Indiana town of Decatur, where most of her family still lives.

Jenna is a Butler University graduate, and loves to cheer on the Bulldogs during basketball season, Go Dawgs!

Jenna lives in West Lafayette with her husband Andy and daughter Quinn.

In her free time, she enjoys going to concerts and visiting the local farmers markets and area festivals. She considers herself a foodie, and loves trying new local restaurants and interesting foods.

Jenna’s key to success is asking questions and listening to what matters most to her clients. Her goal is to build a relationship with each person she gets to work with.

Jenna has been an agent with Farmers® Insurance since 2009 and loves serving the Greater Lafayette and surrounding communities. She likes to volunteer for Junior Achievement and Food Finders Food Bank.

Jenna Isch

(765) 838-2781


Life Insurance Auto Insurance Renters Insurance Lafayette, Indiana

Cheryl Lucas

If you walk into the Farmers® Insurance – Jenna Isch office, Cheryl Lucas is the first smiling face you will see. Cheryl started with Farmers® Insurance – Jenna Isch in July 2012 and currently is the Lead Customer Service and Sales Representative. Cheryl is a licensed insurance agent in both Property and Casualty and Life and Health insurance.

Cheryl grew up in Plainfield, Indiana, the oldest of four children and the only girl. Cheryl moved to Lafayette about 30 years ago to take the job of Program Chair for Computer Programming Technology at Lafayette’s Ivy Tech Campus. She taught there for three years but left to go back to school full-time. Upon graduating from Martin University, she began an 18-year career at Purdue. As an extension of her Purdue job, she did some training for the U.S. Department of Education. After leaving Purdue, she worked for three other insurance companies joining the Farmers® family.

Cheryl has three sons, eight grandkids, and six great-grandkids! Cheryl lives with her dog Loki, a jack-rat terrier. She enjoys playing with him, reading Stephen King novels, watching reality TV and working logic puzzles. She and her friends often get together for WII bowling nights too. Cheryl loves to travel, and one of her favorite destinations is Washington D.C. She loves the museums, especially the Spy Museum and the Metro System.

Cheryl Lucas

(765) 838-2781


Home Insurance Life Insurance in Lafayette, Indiana

Melissa Brandt

Melissa Brandt started with Isch Insurance Services in December 2014 and is currently a licensed customer service and sales representative. Melissa is licensed in Property and Casualty and Life and Health insurance.

Melissa is originally from Monticello, Indiana, and is a graduate of Twin Lakes High School. Melissa moved to Lafayette in August 2007 to attend Purdue University and graduated in December 2011 with a Bachelor of Arts in History. After graduating, she worked at Staples in the Copy & Print Department and as a teller at Regions Bank before becoming an agent at Farmers® Insurance – Jenna Isch.

Melissa lives with her boyfriend, Brandon, and their cat Oreo. She enjoys hanging out with her boyfriend and their amazing friends, binge-watching Netflix and traveling as often as she can.

Melissa Brandt

(765) 838-2781


Car Insurance Quotes Insurance in Lafayette, Indiana

Stevie Smith

Stevie Smith started at Isch Insurance Services in July of 2016 and quickly earned her Property and Casualty insurance license. Stevie works as a Licensed Customer Service and Sales Representative.


Stevie moved to Lafayette in 2010 to attend college at Purdue University, and has called this area her home for the last 6 years. She loves to do anything active especially outdoors. Some of her favorite hobbies include exercise, hiking, kayaking, and cooking.


Stevie recently got married to her husband, Austin, in February of 2016 and they live in West Lafayette with their pets. They love spending time with friends and family and also enjoy going to events in the community.

Stevie Smith

(765) 838-2781


Life and Auto Insurance Renters Insurance Lafayette, Indiana

Community Involvement

Insurance Quotes Renters Insurance House Insurance Lafayette, IN Getting involved in the community is important for our team. Jenna is an active part of the Flashpoint Chapter of Business Networking International and the Community Involvement Committee with Tippy Connect Young Professionals. She serves on the Small Business of the Month Committee with the Greater Lafayette Commerce and is also a member of AWBO, the Association of Women Business Owners. She also enjoys volunteering with Food Finders Food Bank and Junior Achievement. Jenna and her family are also active patrons of local restaurants and area festivals and events.

Join My Team

Car Insurance Quote Insurance Agent in Lafayette, IN The work environment at our agency is fast-paced and fun. If you are passionate about providing excellent, proactive service to help customers find the insurance options that best fit their needs, then you may be interested in a career with us. Contact us today to talk about joining our fantastic team!.

Contact Us

Photos of Farmers® Insurance – Jenna Isch

  • Life Insurance Car Insurance Quote in Lafayette, IN
  • Renters Insurance Auto Insurance House Insurance Lafayette, IN
  • House Insurance Car Insurance Quotes Insurance in Lafayette, IN
  • Car Insurance House Insurance in Lafayette, IN
  • Life Insurance Car Insurance Quote in Lafayette, Indiana
  • Life Insurance in Lafayette, IN Renters Insurance
  • Car Insurance Quote Life Insurance in Lafayette, IN

Take A Tour!

Our Happy Insurance Customers

Jenna is great - very easy to talk to. She obviously knows everything there is to know about Farmers Insurance, and she doesn't just hand you a premade package. She'll talk to you and find out exactly what you need and then create a recommendation for you. Highly recommend if you want personal service and someone you can ask all of your questions!

Robin J

Because of Jenna's detailed approach to quoting my home owners insurance, she found that I had been paying property taxes on having a basement even though I do not have a basement. I received a refund for overpayment of property taxes for the last 3 years and a great home insurance rate as well. Her service is top notch!!!

Shirley P

                                                       Everyone in the office is great! They are always there for me. - Tammy B                                                                  

                                                                                             Jenna Isch is AWESOME! - Mike B                                                                                             

                                                      "Fast service when I had a minor altercation with my vehicle.” – R Strickland                                                          

                                                               “Customer service is always helpful” – Timothy M                                                               

                                                                        “Good prices, good service, great agent!” – Matt H                                                                                 

“Jenna was a very good insurance agent. She was easy to get a hold of and very knowledgeable. I would recommend her to anyone!” – Lindsay E

“Jenna is extremely helpful, punctual, and thorough. She is a personable and professional agent who is very knowledgeable about insurance and will work with you diligently to find what will best suit your insurance needs.”

Brent C

“Jenna is extremely helpful and thoroughly answers any questions that I have in a timely manner. She shows a great deal of concern and empathy towards her clients.”

Jason V

“Jenna really takes the time to look at your situation and see what products you need. She offers a variety of options at a variety of price ranges. She takes the time to sit down with you and go through the options. She also makes sure to answer questions. She always returns calls. I've been very happy with the service she provides me and highly recommend her.”

Niccole K

Thank you. I've become convinced over the years that the maximum benefit from insurance comes from agents and agencies who make a personal commitment to their clients to establish and maintain good working relationships and superior customer service-- thank you again for demonstrating these qualities.

Jeremy G.